With Dr Andi, Homeopath
You've probably felt it before you could name it. Nights that you don't stay asleep. Moods that shift without warning. A sense that your body is running on a different rhythm than before, and you're not always sure why.
If you've read our guide to early signs of perimenopause, you'll know this stage often starts quietly, sometimes years before it's officially recognised. What is less talked about, is what to do next, and whether natural, herbal perimenopause supplements have a genuine place in that plan.
To help answer that, we spoke to Dr Andi, a homeopath. She shared her professional take on natural versus conventional approaches, what to actually look for in a natural formula, and the psychological side of this stage that rarely gets airtime.
Why Natural Approaches Work Differently to Hormone Therapy
“Perimenopause doesn’t manifest in the same way for every woman; therefore, treatment will also not be the same for every woman. Hormone replacement therapy (HRT) supplements exogenous hormones, whereas some herbs have been studied for their potential in lessening symptoms without the direct replacement of hormones.” Dr Andi explains. Conventional hormone therapies work by replacing the hormones that naturally decline during this stage of life. This is the thinking behind most natural perimenopause supplements: rather than replacing hormones directly, they tend to focus on three areas of the body that all play a role in how perimenopause feels day to day:
-
Hormonal support (phytoestrogens) - plant compounds such as red clover and dong quai that bind to the body's oestrogen receptors as ovarian hormone production naturally declines.
-
Adrenal support (adaptogens) - ingredients like ashwagandha and Siberian ginseng, traditionally used to help the body build resilience to the stress that often intensifies during this stage.
-
Nervous system support - botanicals such as passionflower and black cohosh, thought to support calmer sleep and steadier mood by working with the nervous system, rather than hormone levels directly.
“It's not about choosing one intervention over the other,” Dr Andi says. “It's about choosing the option which is best for you. Often the best option for one person may not be at all suitable for another.”
What Phytoestrogens and Adaptogens Actually Do
The word “phytoestrogen” sounds clinical, but the idea behind it is simple. “Phytoestrogens are plant-derived compounds that can mildly interact with oestrogen receptors,” says Dr Andi. “Some phytoestrogens, such as isoflavones found in soy and red clover, have been studied for their potential to ease symptoms associated with menopause such as hot flashes. Their effects are not equivalent to HRT but may provide relief for mild symptoms.”
Her way of explaining it: think of phytoestrogens as plant compounds that have a mild effect on oestrogen receptors as opposed to total replacement of oestrogen itself. That gentle nudge won't do what hormone replacement therapy does, but for many women with milder symptoms, it can be enough to feel a noticeable difference.
Adaptogens work on a different system entirely, supporting the adrenal glands and the body's stress response, which shifts alongside hormones during this stage. And contrary to a common assumption, “natural” doesn't mean “weak.” Plant medicines are active compounds that can bring about real physiological change, Dr Andi notes, and like any medicine, they take consistent use over weeks, not days, before their effects become noticeable. “Think of them like exercise. You won't see results after a single gym session. Similarly, some phytochemicals may take time for their effects to be noticeable depending on the individual patient, dose, and the treatment being used.”
The Psychological Side of Perimenopause No One Warns You About
Ask Dr Andi what women don't know about perimenopause, and she doesn't start with hot flashes.
“What women don't realise is how big a shift it can be psychologically. A shorter temper, mood swings, brain fog, and the list goes on. These aspects often leave patients feeling that they no longer even recognise themselves, which can be far scarier than some would think.”
It's a part of the experience that gets far less attention than the physical symptoms, and one that can make women feel like something is wrong with them. Dr Andi is clear that there isn't. “Hormones are exceptionally powerful chemical messengers which significantly influence a plethora of systems in the body. A significant biological shift is taking place, and to become aware of it is to regain your power over it.”
Consistency, and Knowing When to See Your GP
Natural approaches may be helpful for mild symptoms, particularly in the earlier stages of perimenopause, Dr Andi says. If symptoms become severe enough to affect daily life, or if there's a personal history of blood clots, cancer, cardiovascular disease or unusual bleeding, a GP or gynaecologist should always be part of the conversation.
Where a natural perimenopause supplement is appropriate, consistency is what makes the difference. The body needs time to shift its physiology back toward balance, and that happens gradually, not overnight. You can read more about building that kind of steady, everyday support in How to Support Your Body Through Perimenopause, Naturally.
A Message for Women Just Starting Out
Asked what she'd say to a woman just entering perimenopause and feeling lost, Dr Andi kept it simple: “Each woman's journey is different. What may have worked for one woman may not work for another, and that is why there is power in finding the protocol that works best for you.”
Perimenopause isn't a single, predictable experience, physically or psychologically, and there's no single way through it. Understanding what's actually happening in your body, and knowing that support looks different for everyone, is often the first step to feeling more like yourself again.
For more insights like this, explore the Be Bright Journal.
Disclaimer:
This article is intended for general information and does not replace an individual medical assessment. If you are experiencing persistent, severe, or unusual symptoms, or are considering a supplement while taking medication, discuss your options with an appropriately qualified healthcare professional.
